About Pie Guys
Using fresh ingredients, and a meticulously hand crafted recipe, we strive to bring you the freshest, most delicious pizza experience your taste buds have ever encountered.
Using fresh ingredients, and a meticulously hand crafted recipe, we strive to bring you the freshest, most delicious pizza experience your taste buds have ever encountered. Two brothers that have dreamed of opening their own pizzeria their entire lives. With over 14 years of combined experience, working in and out of pizzerias, learning the techniques and operations, they bring to you, Pie Guys Pizza.
I had gone looking for a new pizza place as my current options were getting a bit old. I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of the pizza. I’d had personally gotten the “grandma’s pie” and it is regular square pizza but with garlic bread taste. Not a single person I’ve known has not loved it. Would highly recommend this place!
Ambedo
2021-09-14
I order a slice and a cheese steak sandwich last night was great pizza is thin crust the bread was fresh and delicious cooked cheese steak. They have a great menu to choose from. I would order again from here
stan s
2021-08-15
Decent, the garlic knots were a little doughy
Benjamin Bohnhoff
2021-08-08
Grandma slice was very good!
Tatiana Porras
2021-07-22
Wow!! We had a great experience at Jersey Guys Pizza. Ordered the Denver Pie (a must try!) and the veggie Bar Pie. Both were awesome. Carmine was super friendly and the service was great. Highly recommend.
Jason Tamashausky
2021-06-17
Friendly staff.
Love the options here and the customization you can get out of the pizzas. I am new to Wayne but will come back for more here.
Dominick Luizza
2021-05-18
Love the pizza
Jenny Jenny
2021-05-15
Stayed in Wayne NJ for 2 nights this week. Ordered from here because of reviews and because they offered no contact delivery to my hotel and tip was already paid. Last night, I ordered a small cheese pizza, sweet potato fries and Philly chicken for my son and I, food was great. However, the person that delivered, called to let me know it was here, so like last time I expected it to be no contact outside my room.....as I opened the door to get it.....the person was there to hand it to me. I specifically asked for no contact delivery. Please if someone else asks for that, respect it. But I definitely recommend their food, it's really good and not bad prices!
Chantel Marie
2021-03-21